1. Health

Book Review: "Rules" by Cynthia Lord

About.com Rating 4.5 Star Rating
Be the first to write a review

From , former About.com Guide

Updated May 29, 2009

About.com Health's Disease and Condition content is reviewed by the Medical Review Board

The Bottom Line

If you, like me, enjoy reading children's literature - this is a "must read." Lord is up there with major writers like Jerry Spinelli and Beverly Cleary as a creator of real, fresh, believable children who experience the world in all its colors. For families and teachers with autistic children in their lives, this novel is a terrific way to open the door to conversations.
<!--#echo encoding="none" var="lcp" -->

Pros

  • A great book for siblings of children with autism
  • Great fun for parents as well
  • Compelling, believable characters
  • Warm and positive without being gooey or maudlin
  • Opens doors for conversation with kids and adults

Cons

  • This is a novel for kids, so adults might find it simplistic
  • The character with autism is not explored deeply

Description

  • A novel for children ages nine to 12
  • Disabled characters are full and real
  • Well-written and worthy of being on any reading list
  • A great tool for opening conversations
  • Provides insight into autism and cerebral palsy

Guide Review - Book Review: "Rules" by Cynthia Lord

I loved this book - read it through in one sitting, which is unusual for me. For one thing, it's one of the very few books with "autism" in the description that is a novel, and heck - novels are fun to read. For another thing, Cynthia Lord is a very talented children's fiction writer. What I really enjoyed, though, was seeing autism through the eyes of a sibling who is aware of all the ups, downs, frustrations and joys of autism in the family.

Two things surprised and interested me. First, I realized that the sibling relationship between Catherine and her autistic brother David is not that different from any sibling relationship. He drives her crazy and gets special treatment - but there's a unique bond between them that is unaffected by a diagnosis. This seemed very real to me, and echoed my experience with my own kids.

Second, I was interested to see that Lord took the time-honored approach of making this book all about the kids - and NOT the adults. As a result, mom and dad are emotionally absent. This made me feel a bit sad, but to be honest, it seemed fairly realistic.

I could easily see using this novel at school or at home as an entree to a discussion of relationships and disabilities (the story also includes a very three-dimensional character with severe cerebral palsy). A terrific addition to home and school libraries.

<!--#echo encoding="none" var="lcp" -->

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.

We comply with the HONcode standard
for trustworthy health
information: verify here.